Skip to content
SPSDPSPlanning & Building Tools

Waterproofing systems compared

Waterproofing fails mostly because of poor surface preparation, missed corners and skipped curing - not because of the product category. Use this to shortlist, then follow the maker's method statement.

Cost tiers are RELATIVE only (lower / medium / higher). SPSDPS does not publish current prices - get written local quotations.

The short answer

Waterproofing fails mostly from poor surface prep and skipped details, not from the product choice alone.

If your situation is this, choose that
If you need...ConsiderWhy
Bathroom floor under tilesCementitious or polymer-modified coatingCommon and accepted for wet areas when applied correctly.
Movement-prone areas or balconiesFlexible polymer or PU membraneBridges small cracks; needs correct surface and protection.
Roof terraceMembrane or coating system with protection layerFollow the maker's method and test for leaks.
Basement or water tankCrystalline or system chosen by a specialistHigher risk areas need expert detailing.

All options at a glance

All options at a glance
OptionRelative costBest forWatch out for
Cementitious coatingLower to mediumBathrooms, sunken slabs, tanks (as specified).Limited flexibility at moving cracks
Acrylic / polymer-modified coatingMediumTerraces and balconies as specified by the maker.Not all suit constant immersion
PU liquid membraneHigherTerraces and balconies with movement.Moisture-sensitive substrate prep
Bitumen sheet membrane (APP/SBS)Medium to higherLarge flat roofs.Needs torching or adhesive skill
Crystalline (integral / slurry)Medium to higherBasements, tanks and retaining walls.Needs sound concrete

Compare side by side

Choose up to 3 to compare

The check mark shows an option that has figures verified against a cited source.

Cementitious coating

Standard: Product-specific

Relative cost: Lower to medium

Specifications

No standard values quoted. Compare using the product data sheet and a batch test report.

Advantages

  • Bonds well to concrete and masonry
  • Familiar to most applicators

Disadvantages

  • Limited flexibility at moving cracks
  • Needs curing

Best for

Bathrooms, sunken slabs, tanks (as specified).

Avoid

Surfaces that move or crack.

Acrylic / polymer-modified coating

Standard: Product-specific

Relative cost: Medium

Specifications

No standard values quoted. Compare using the product data sheet and a batch test report.

Advantages

  • Flexible, bridges fine cracks
  • Easy on small areas

Disadvantages

  • Not all suit constant immersion
  • UV exposure may need a protective layer

Best for

Terraces and balconies as specified by the maker.

Avoid

Standing water unless rated.

PU liquid membrane

Standard: Product-specific

Relative cost: Higher

Specifications

No standard values quoted. Compare using the product data sheet and a batch test report.

Advantages

  • Highly elastic
  • Seamless

Disadvantages

  • Moisture-sensitive substrate prep
  • Higher cost

Best for

Terraces and balconies with movement.

Avoid

Damp substrates without the right primer.

Common mistakes

  • Skipping corner fillets, pipe collars and the wall upturn.
  • Not doing a water ponding test before tiling.
  • Tiling over the coating before the maker's recoat or cure time.

Ask the shop

  • What is the exact surface preparation?
  • How many coats and what thickness or coverage?
  • What written warranty is offered?

Words you will hear

Upturn
Coating carried up the wall above the floor.
Ponding test
Filling an area with water to watch for leaks.
Fillet
A small curved cement fillet at the wall-floor corner.

Next steps

How to choose

  • Fix leaking pipes and cracks first.
  • Treat corners, pipe penetrations and drains with the system's detailing.
  • Do a water-ponding test (commonly 24-48 hours) before tiling, as your contractor specifies.
  • Keep the application record and warranty.

Sources and how far to trust them

Limits of this comparison: Qualitative guidance only. Consumption, thickness and curing times are product-specific.

This category uses general professional guidance, not quoted standard values. Read the product data sheet and ask for test reports.

Standards are revised. Confirm any value you rely on against the current edition on the BIS website. Information is for planning, not a specification.

More services comparisons